The Reviews

Checked in, honestly reviewed.

Every stay paid for and slept in. Scored out of ten, with what I paid, the room to ask for, and the tip I’d give a friend.

Next review: The Tasman, Hobart. Upcoming stays: Crown Towers Sydney in December, W Melbourne in January.

Review No. 01 · Brisbane

The Calile Hotel

Five nights on James Street for the Chain Social retreat. Checked in 22 August, checked out 27 August 2026. Paid for, slept in, swum in.

Would I book again? Already planning it. This is the hotel I measure the others against now.
The Calile pool from above at dusk, lit turquoise, ringed by mint loungers with folded robes
Calile guest room with a concrete ceiling, linen curtains, cork headboard and a low daybed under the window
Breakfast on a pink marble table: eggs benedict with smoked salmon, fruit, yoghurt, a green juice and a pot of tea
World’s 50 Best
No. 83 · 2026
Previously
No. 12 · No. 25 · No. 34
Where
James Street, Fortitude Valley
Opened
2018
Design
Richards & Spence
Rooms
175
Robes
Venroy linen, for The Calile
My room
Balcony Room, pool view
Paid
$2,900 · 5 nights
Dates
22 – 27 Aug 2026
Spa
KAILO, in the building

The Departure Society score

The room
10/10
Service
10/10
Food
10/10
Facilities
10/10
Return?
Yes

The short version

The Calile is the only Australian hotel to appear on the World’s 50 Best list every year since it began, ranked 83rd in the world for 2026, and after five nights I understand why. It is calm, warm, beautifully designed, and the staff are some of the best I have come across anywhere in Australia. It is quietly luxurious rather than showy, and every detail has been thought about.

The room

I had a Balcony Room looking over the pool, five nights for $2,900, and it is the one to ask for. Pale concrete ceilings, cork floors, linen curtains that filter Brisbane light into something soft, and a low daybed under the window that I used more than the bed. The robe on the hanger is Venroy linen made for the hotel, which tells you most of what you need to know about the level of thought here. The tea is Love Tea. The lamps are the little glowing kind you want to take home.

Mornings

The pool is the reason to stay. Turquoise tile, mint loungers, robes already folded on them, and almost nobody in it before eight. A morning swim here is the best way to start the day, and the mornings I did were the best mornings of the trip.

The gym, and Caren

I came to Brisbane a few months out from knee surgery, cautious about training, and booked a session with Caren, the hotel’s trainer. She was amazing: patient, precise, properly knowledgeable about what a recovering knee can and can’t do, and she gave me the best full-body workout I’ve had in a long time. If you are staying and you train, book her. It was one of the best hours of the trip.

The staff are amazing. Genuinely warm, genuinely helpful, and nothing was ever too much trouble.

Food

Breakfast on the pink marble table in the room became a ritual: eggs benedict with smoked salmon, a bowl of fruit, a green juice and a pot of tea, every single day. Our welcome dinner was at Bianca, and it was the right call. Downstairs, Hellenika does the Greek food people cross the city for, and the lobby bar is exactly where you want to be at six.

The spa

KAILO, the wellness spa, is right there in the building. I didn’t make it this time, which tells you how full five days on James Street can get. It is first on the list for the next stay.

Location

James Street is the best address in Brisbane for a certain kind of week: the good boutiques, the good coffee, and restaurants you can walk to in a linen dress. The city is a short ride away when you need it, and you rarely do.

The Calile’s curved white-brick facade with THE CALILE lettering against a blue sky
James Street
The Calile gym: three Technogym treadmills in front of a wide window, cork floors and timber walls
The gym
A pink spritz over ice with an orange wedge and paper straws on a marble bar
The members’ spritz
Book it ifYou want a resort feeling inside a city, you like a morning swim, and you’d rather a hotel be quietly excellent than loudly luxurious.
The tipSign up to Friends of The Calile before you book. Members get a discounted room rate, and when you download the app you’re welcomed with a free spritz in the lobby bar. Do this first, then book.

Pack this

BikiniBig sunglassesThe black dress, for BiancaLinen for the daytimeHeels you can walk James Street inGym set for CarenChanel MademoiselleA book you won’t read on the daybedAn empty bag for the boutiques
Review No. 02 · Hobart

DoubleTree by Hilton Hobart

A staycation in my own city at the end of the holidays. Checked in 30 January, checked out 31 January 2026. Paid for, slept in, swum in, sauna’d in.

The perfect Hobart staycation if you’re a local. Warm cookie, cold champagne, a sauna, and checkout at midday.
Mikaela in a white robe sitting on the bed beneath a photograph of Hobart’s waterfront
A bottle of Josef Chromy Tasmanian cuvée on ice with two glasses and a handwritten welcome note
The harbour view from the room: Hobart’s waterfront and the hills beyond
Where
179 Macquarie Street, Hobart
Opened
October 2024
Rooms
206
Claim to fame
Tasmania’s first Hilton
Restaurant
Leatherwood Bar & Kitchen
Wellness
Heated indoor pool, sauna, gym
My room
King Guest Room, Water View
Paid
$279 · 1 night
Dates
30 – 31 Jan 2026
Check out
12pm
On arrival
A warm cookie. Always.

The Departure Society score

The room
10/10
Service
10/10
Food
10/10
Facilities
10/10
Return?
Yes

The short version

Hobart’s first Hilton, and it feels new in the best way: everything works, everything is clean, and the people are lovely. I checked in to a bottle of Tasmanian sparkling on ice and a handwritten note, which is exactly the kind of thing that makes me loyal to a hotel. It is a very easy place to be.

The cookie

Every DoubleTree in the world hands you a chocolate chip cookie at check in. I’d heard about it. I can now confirm it is warm, it is enormous, and it is the correct way to begin a stay.

The room

I booked a standard room for $279 and was upgraded on arrival to a King Guest Room with a water view, which set the tone for everything that followed. A big bed, a big photograph of the waterfront above it, and floor-to-ceiling windows with sheer curtains that turn Hobart into something soft. The view is the harbour: water, boats and the hills behind, straight from the bed. It is not trying to be a boutique hotel and it doesn’t need to be: it is comfortable, quiet and generous with space.

Pool and sauna

This is the reason to come if you live here. A heated indoor pool and a proper cedar sauna, and I alternated between them for most of an afternoon. Swim, sauna, swim, sauna. It is the best reset you can get in Hobart without leaving the city.

Warm cookie on the way in. Cold champagne in the room. A sauna in the afternoon and a steak at night. That is a good day.

Food

Leatherwood, the restaurant downstairs, was the surprise of the stay. The cocktails are seriously good. Charred sourdough with cultured butter, Tasmanian scallops served in the shell, and a steak that was, honestly, perfection. If you only come for dinner, come for dinner.

The staff

Beautiful. Genuinely warm from the front desk to the restaurant, and quick to help without ever hovering.

The 12pm checkout

Checkout is midday, which on a staycation is the whole point. A slow breakfast, one more swim, a late shower, and still out the door without rushing.

Cedar sauna with timber benches and a stove
The sauna
A grilled steak with a swirl of jus and a glazed onion at Leatherwood
The steak, Leatherwood
Tasmanian scallops served in their shells
The scallops
Book it ifYou live in Hobart and need a reset without the airport, or you’re visiting and want somewhere central, new and easy with a very good restaurant underneath you.
The tipBook dinner at Leatherwood when you book the room, and plan your afternoon around the pool and sauna. Then use every minute of the 12pm checkout.

Pack this

The dress, for date night at LeatherwoodBikini for the poolA maxi dress to walk the city inHeels for dinner, flats for SalamancaBig sunglasses
Review No. 03 · Melbourne

Crown Towers Melbourne

Five stays. Three in a Deluxe Room, one in a Studio, and most recently the Premier Suite. All paid for by me.

Beautiful hotel, beautiful rooms, beautiful food. The service on my Premier Suite stay didn’t match the price, and that’s the honest version.
Champagne on ice on a side table with the Melbourne skyline and the Yarra through the window at Crown Towers
The Premier Suite at Crown Towers: curved lounge, bedroom, marble bathroom
Deluxe room at Crown Towers with a king bed, desk and floor-to-ceiling window over the Yarra and Flinders Street
Where
8 Whiteman Street, Southbank
Opened
1997
Deluxe Room
$319 · stayed 3 times
Studio
$540 · stayed once
Premier Suite
$585 · stayed once
Eat
Gradi, Moët & Chandon Oyster Bar, Conservatory
Wellness
Crown Spa, indoor pool, Aqua Retreat
Shop
Prada, Louis Vuitton, Peter Alexander, Koko Black, Cotton On Body, Guess
Members
Crown Direct

The Departure Society score

The suite
7/10
Food
10/10
Facilities
10/10
Wait times
3/10
Return?
Probably not

The short version

Crown Towers has always been my Melbourne hotel. The river views, the restaurants downstairs, the shopping, the lobby. I’ve stayed five times and I’ve loved it. My last stay was in the Premier Suite, and it was the first time the service let the hotel down.

The rooms

The Deluxe Room is the one I keep coming back to. $319 a night, a king bed, and a floor-to-ceiling window with the Yarra and Flinders Street in it. Ask for a river view, as high up as they’ll give you. The Studio is $540 and gives you more space and more window. Worth it for two nights or more.

The Premier Suite is $585. It is stunning: a curved wall of windows, two lounges, a marble bathroom with a big bath, a bedroom with a huge padded headboard. Breakfast at the dining table with that view was the best part of the stay. But I’d give it a 7, because you get the same view and the same champagne in the Deluxe for $266 less. The extra isn’t worth it. Spend it on dinner.

Food

Perfect, every time. Gradi is my favourite Italian in Melbourne and it’s downstairs. I love the Moët & Chandon Oyster Bar for a glass and a dozen before dinner. Conservatory does the best buffet breakfast in the city, just know it gets very busy and there are a lot of staff moving around you, but the food is great. Room service was excellent; there’s a $10 tray fee on every order, so factor that in. And there’s a food court downstairs for when you’ve had a few too many champagnes at The Palms and can’t face a restaurant.

Shopping

You don’t have to leave the building. Peter Alexander, Koko Black, Cotton On Body and Guess are my go-tos, and I always leave with more than I came with. When I’m feeling brave, Prada and Louis Vuitton are both here too, and they are my favourites. Dangerous, in the best way.

Spa and pool

The indoor pool is lovely and quiet in the morning. Crown Spa is beautiful. I had an event style booked for this stay and they cancelled on the day, which was disappointing, but I’ve had good experiences there before.

The service on this stay

This is the hard part to write, because I love this hotel. But I paid $585 a night and this is what happened.

My luggage wasn’t brought to the room. I waited an hour after check-in and had to call to chase it. The champagne that comes with the suite wasn’t there either; I had to call for that too. I ordered a bucket of ice and it took fifty minutes and three calls to guest services. After housekeeping, I came back to someone else’s belongings in my room. Late checkout was confirmed, then unclear, then confirmed again once I followed up. And I was overcharged by $325 on the bill, including champagne I’d been told was complimentary. They fixed it, but I had to go through every line to find it.

Everyone I spoke to was polite and lovely. None of this was anyone being rude. It was just that at this price, I shouldn’t have had to keep ringing to check on things that should already have been done.

A 10/10 hotel to look at, with service that didn’t keep up. I love Crown, but I think it’s time to try somewhere new.
Breakfast at the suite’s dining table with the Melbourne skyline
Breakfast, Premier Suite
Crown teacup, tea with Koko Black chocolate, laptop on the bed with the view, pillows
The small things
A glass of champagne held up against the Melbourne skyline from the window
The view
Book it ifYou want the Melbourne hotel with the river view and the best restaurants in the city a lift ride away. Book the Deluxe Room. It’s the best value in the building.
The tipSign up to Crown Direct before you book, members pay less. Book Gradi for the first night. And if you can, come in January for the Australian Open. The whole city is buzzing and the tennis players stay here.

Pack this

The black dress, for GradiBikini for the poolHeels for the lobbyFlats for SouthbankBig sunglassesSomething white, for the Open